The Chinese Pharmacopoeia (2020 edition) requires that the methanol extract of YCH should not be less than 20.0% [2], with no other quality evaluation indicators specified. The results of this study show that the contents of the methanol extracts of the wild and cultivated samples both met the pharmacopoeia standard, and there was no significant difference among them. Therefore, there was no apparent quality difference between wild and cultivated samples, according to that index. However, the contents of total sterols and total flavonoids in the wild samples were significantly higher than those in the cultivated samples. Further metabolomic analysis revealed abundant metabolite diversity between the wild and cultivated samples. Additionally, 97 significantly different metabolites were screened out, which are listed in the Supplementary Table S2. Among these significantly different metabolites are β-sitosterol (ID is M397T42) and quercetin derivatives (M447T204_2), which have been reported to be active ingredients. Previously unreported constituents, such as trigonelline (M138T291_2), betaine (M118T277_2), fustin (M269T36), rotenone (M241T189), arctiin (M557T165) and loganic acid (M399T284_2), were also included among the differential metabolites. These components play various roles in anti-oxidation, anti-inflammatory, scavenging free radicals, anti-cancer and treating atherosclerosis and, therefore, might constitute putative novel active components in YCH. The content of active ingredients determines the efficacy and quality of the medicinal materials [7]. In summary, methanol extract as the only YCH quality evaluation index has some limitations, and more specific quality markers need to be further explored. There were significant differences in total sterols, total flavonoids and the contents of many other differential metabolites between the wild and cultivated YCH; so, there were potentially some quality differences between them. At the same time, the newly discovered potential active ingredients in YCH might have an important reference value for the study of the functional basis of YCH and the further development of YCH resources.
The importance of genuine medicinal materials has long been recognized in the specific region of origin for producing Chinese herbal medicines of excellent quality [
8]. High quality is an essential attribute of genuine medicinal materials, and habitat is an important factor affecting the quality of such materials. Ever since YCH began to be used as medicine, it has long been dominated by wild YCH. Following the successful introduction and domestication of YCH in Ningxia in the 1980s, the source of Yinchaihu medicinal materials gradually shifted from wild to cultivated YCH. According to a previous investigation into YCH sources [
9] and the field investigation of our research group, there are significant differences in the distribution areas of the cultivated and wild medicinal materials. The wild YCH is mainly distributed in the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of the Shaanxi Province, adjacent to the arid zone of Inner Mongolia and central Ningxia. In particular, the desert steppe in these areas is the most suitable habitat for YCH growth. In contrast, the cultivated YCH is mainly distributed to the south of the wild distribution area, such as Tongxin County (Cultivated I) and its surrounding areas, which has become the largest cultivation and production base in China, and Pengyang County (Cultivated II), which is located in a more southern area and is another producing area for cultivated YCH. Moreover, the habitats of the above two cultivated areas are not desert steppe. Therefore, in addition to the mode of production, there are also significant differences in the habitat of the wild and cultivated YCH. Habitat is an important factor affecting the quality of herbal medicinal materials. Different habitats will affect the formation and accumulation of secondary metabolites in the plants, thereby affecting the quality of medicinal products [
10,
11]. Therefore, the significant differences in the contents of total flavonoids and total sterols and the expression of the 53 metabolites that we found in this study might be the result of field management and habitat differences.
One of the main ways that the environment influences the quality of medicinal materials is by exerting stress on the source plants. Moderate environmental stress tends to stimulate the accumulation of secondary metabolites [
12,
13]. The growth/differentiation balance hypothesis states that, when nutrients are in sufficient supply, plants primarily grow, whereas when nutrients are deficient, plants mainly differentiate and produce more secondary metabolites [
14]. Drought stress caused by water deficiency is the main environmental stress faced by plants in arid areas. In this study, the water condition of the cultivated YCH is more abundant, with annual precipitation levels significantly higher than those for the wild YCH (water supply for Cultivated I was about 2 times that of Wild; Cultivated II was about 3.5 times that of Wild). In addition, the soil in the wild environment is sandy soil, but the soil in the farmland is clay soil. Compared with clay, sandy soil has a poor water retention capacity and is more likely to aggravate drought stress. At the same time, the cultivation process was often accompanied by watering, so the degree of drought stress was low. Wild YCH grows in harsh natural arid habitats, and therefore it may suffer more serious drought stress.
Osmoregulation is an important physiological mechanism by which plants cope with drought stress, and alkaloids are important osmotic regulators in higher plants [
15]. Betaines are water-soluble alkaloid quaternary ammonium compounds and can act as osmoprotectants. Drought stress can reduce the osmotic potential of cells, while osmoprotectants preserve and maintain the structure and integrity of biological macromolecules, and effectively alleviate the damage caused by drought stress to plants [
16]. For example, under drought stress, the betaine content of sugar beet and Lycium barbarum increased significantly [
17,
18]. Trigonelline is a regulator of cell growth, and under drought stress, it can extend the length of the plant cell cycle, inhibit cell growth and lead to cell volume shrinkage. The relative increase in solute concentration in the cell enables the plant to achieve osmotic regulation and enhance its ability to resist drought stress [
19]. JIA X [
20] found that, with an increase in drought stress, Astragalus membranaceus (a source of traditional Chinese medicine) produced more trigonelline, which acts to regulate osmotic potential and improve the ability to resist drought stress. Flavonoids have also been shown to play an important role in plant resistance to drought stress [
21,
22]. A large number of studies have confirmed that moderate drought stress was conducive to the accumulation of flavonoids. Lang Duo-Yong et al. [
23] compared the effects of drought stress on YCH by controlling water-holding capacity in the field. It was found that drought stress inhibited the growth of roots to a certain extent, but in moderate and severe drought stress (40% field water holding capacity), the total flavonoid content in YCH increased. Meanwhile, under drought stress, phytosterols can act to regulate cell membrane fluidity and permeability, inhibit water loss and improve stress resistance [
24,
25]. Therefore, the increased accumulation of total flavonoids, total sterols, betaine, trigonelline and other secondary metabolites in wild YCH might be related to high-intensity drought stress.
In this study, KEGG pathway enrichment analysis was performed on the metabolites that were found to be significantly different between the wild and cultivated YCH. The enriched metabolites included those involved in the pathways of ascorbate and aldarate metabolism, aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis, histidine metabolism and beta-alanine metabolism. These metabolic pathways are closely related to plant stress resistance mechanisms. Among them, ascorbate metabolism plays an important role in plant antioxidant production, carbon and nitrogen metabolism, stress resistance and other physiological functions [
26]; aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis is an important pathway for protein formation [
27,
28], which is involved in the synthesis of stress-resistant proteins. Both histidine and β-alanine pathways can enhance plant tolerance to environmental stress [
29,
30]. This further indicates that the differences in metabolites between the wild and cultivated YCH was closely related to the processes of stress resistance.
Soil is the material basis for the growth and development of medicinal plants. Nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) in soil are important nutrient elements for the growth and development of plants. Soil organic matter also contains N, P, K, Zn, Ca, Mg and other macroelements and trace elements required for medicinal plants. Excessive or deficient nutrients, or unbalanced nutrient ratios, will affect the growth and development and the quality of medicinal materials, and different plants have different nutrient requirements [
31,
32,
33]. For example, a low N stress promoted the synthesis of alkaloids in Isatis indigotica, and was beneficial to the accumulation of flavonoids in plants such as Tetrastigma hemsleyanum, Crataegus pinnatifida Bunge and Dichondra repens Forst. In contrast, too much N inhibited the accumulation of flavonoids in species such as Erigeron breviscapus, Abrus cantoniensis and Ginkgo biloba, and affected the quality of medicinal materials [
34]. The application of P fertilizer was effective in increasing the content of glycyrrhizic acid and dihydroacetone in Ural licorice [
35]. When the application amount exceeded 0·12 kg·m−2, the total flavonoid content in Tussilago farfara decreased [
36]. The application of a P fertilizer had a negative effect on the content of polysaccharides in the traditional Chinese medicine rhizoma polygonati [
37], but a K fertilizer was effective in increasing its content of saponins [
38]. Applying 450 kg·hm−2 K fertilizer was the best for the growth and saponin accumulation of two-year-old Panax notoginseng [
39]. Under the ratio of N:P:K = 2:2:1, the total amounts of hydrothermal extract, harpagide and harpagoside were the highest [
40]. The high ratio of N, P and K was beneficial to promote the growth of Pogostemon cablin and increase the content of volatile oil. A low ratio of N, P and K increased the content of the main effective components of Pogostemon cablin stem leaf oil [
41]. YCH is a barren-soil-tolerant plant, and it might have specific requirements for nutrients such as N, P and K. In this study, compared with the cultivated YCH, the soil of the wild YCH plants was relatively barren: the soil contents of organic matter, total N, total P and total K were about 1/10, 1/2, 1/3 and 1/3 those of the cultivated plants, respectively. Therefore, the differences in soil nutrients might be another reason for the differences between the metabolites detected in the cultivated and wild YCH. Weibao Ma et al. [
42] found that the application of a certain amount of N fertilizer and P fertilizer significantly improved the yield and quality of seeds. However, the effect of nutrient elements on the quality of YCH is not clear, and fertilization measures to improve the quality of medicinal materials need further study.
Chinese herbal medicines have the characteristics of “Favorable habitats promote yield, and unfavorable habitats improve quality” [
43]. In the process of a gradual shift from wild to cultivated YCH, the habitat of the plants changed from the arid and barren desert steppe to fertile farmland with more abundant water. The habitat of the cultivated YCH is superior and the yield is higher, which is helpful to meet the market demand. However, this superior habitat led to significant changes in the metabolites of YCH; whether this is conducive to improving the quality of YCH and how to achieve a high-quality production of YCH through science-based cultivation measures will require further research.
Simulative habitat cultivation is a method of simulating the habitat and environmental conditions of wild medicinal plants, based on knowledge of the long-term adaptation of the plants to specific environmental stresses [
43]. By simulating various environmental factors that affect the wild plants, especially the original habitat of plants used as sources of authentic medicinal materials, the approach uses scientific design and innovative human intervention to balance the growth and secondary metabolism of Chinese medicinal plants [
43]. The methods aims to achieve the optimal arrangements for the development of high-quality medicinal materials. Simulative habitat cultivation should provide an effective way for the high-quality production of YCH even when the pharmacodynamic basis, quality markers and response mechanisms to environmental factors are unclear. Accordingly, we suggest that scientific design and field management measures in the cultivation and production of YCH should be carried out with reference to the environmental characteristics of wild YCH, such as arid, barren and sandy soil conditions. At the same time, it is also hoped that researchers will conduct more in-depth research on the functional material basis and quality markers of YCH. These studies can provide more effective evaluation criteria for YCH, and promote the high-quality production and sustainable development of the industry.